Why Your Best Employees Leave (and What Small Businesses Can Do About It)

When a top performer resigns, leaders often say the same thing: “We had no idea they were unhappy.”

In reality, most high-performing employees don’t leave suddenly. They leave after months – or years – of quiet disengagement. Understanding why your best people leave is one of the most important retention challenges facing small and mid-sized businesses today.

The Myth: People Leave for More Money

Compensation matters. But in exit interviews, pay is rarely the only reason – and often not the primary one. High performers most often leave because of:

• Poor manager relationships
• Lack of growth or career path
• Feeling undervalued or invisible
• Burnout from unclear priorities
• Lack of flexibility or work-life balance

Money becomes the final reason when the underlying issues go unaddressed.

The Manager Effect

Study after study shows that employees don’t leave companies – they leave managers. In small businesses, managers are often:

• Promoted for technical skill, not people skill
• Given little to no leadership training
• Expected to “figure it out” on their own

Without support, even well-intentioned managers can drive disengagement without realizing it.

The Warning Signs Leaders Miss

High performers rarely complain loudly. Instead, they:

• Stop volunteering for extra projects
• Pull back from meetings and discussions
• Use more PTO or sick time
• Become quieter and less visible
• Update their LinkedIn profile

By the time a resignation hits, the decision is already made.

What Actually Improves Retention

Retention isn’t about ping-pong tables or free snacks. It’s about three fundamentals:

1. Strong Manager Capability – Train managers on feedback, coaching, and difficult conversations.
2. Clear Growth Paths – Employees stay when they can see a future – even if promotions are limited.
3. Regular Stay Conversations – Don’t wait for exit interviews. Ask current employees:
   • What keeps you here?
   • What might cause you to leave?
   • What support do you need right now?

A Small Change with a Big Impact

One of the simplest retention tools is a quarterly “stay interview” with high performers. Thirty minutes of listening can prevent months of recruiting, onboarding, and lost productivity.

Final Thoughts

Replacing a top performer costs far more than retaining one. The organizations that win on retention aren’t perfect. They’re simply paying attention – before their best people walk out the door.

Article courtesy of Ahola.

Click here for more News & Resources.