Working Parents Fear Job Loss During Pandemic
October 7, 2020
By Heather Nezich, courtesy of SBAM Approved Partner ASE
More than half of working parents fear being a parent is a strike against them in the workplace during COVID-19. According to the new Catalyst-CNBC survey, The Impact of COVID-19 on Working Parents, nearly 40% of working parents say that their employer does not have enough benefits for parents to support blended or virtual learning amidst the uncertainty of students of all ages returning to school.
In the survey of 1,000 working parents in the U.S., 57% of parents fear they will be the first group to be negatively affected by employer decisions. They also see a risk associated with reaching out to access, or asking for, benefits, fearing they will be penalized or even terminated:
- Four in ten parents (41%) say they have less job security than they did pre-pandemic; and 38% say they fear being penalized for being a working parent
- 41% of mothers and 36% of fathers say they have had to hide their caregiving struggles
- 42% fear that it would be a risk to their employment to take advantage of childcare offerings or benefits available to them through their workplace
- 39% worry that they’ll be terminated if they ask for help
Additionally, more than a third of parents say they are not aware of the plans their employers have in place for parents, or whether these plans simply do not exist at their company. Nearly half (49%) of working mothers and 39% of working fathers say they are not aware of any employer plans to help with childcare.
The survey also revealed other gender disparities in perceptions of parents’ employers:
- Working fathers are more likely to say their employer is supporting them with paid leave (26% of men versus 16% of women; and 17% of men say their employer provides additional personal time off vs. 10% of women)
- 49% of fathers report that their workplace has been proactive in expanding benefits since COVID-19 began, versus 37% of women
- Working mothers are more likely to say that their organization has not been proactive at all (30% of working mothers versus 20% of working fathers).
“Working parents are combatting insurmountable challenges and impossible choices during the pandemic,” said Lorraine Hariton, President & CEO of Catalyst. “We know some companies have stepped up in big ways to support parents during this time, but as this crisis continues, many of these strategies are fraying. It’s essential that employers view this as an opportunity to lead and help other organizations rethink how work gets done and take action to find creative ways to give employees the support they need.”
Parents Feel Guilty
The disruption of COVID-19 has left parents across genders, race or ethnicity, and job levels feeling guilty about how they’re managing work and family responsibilities during the pandemic. Over half of parents, 54%, said they feel guilty working because they are not able to attend to their caregiving responsibilities, while 43% said they feel guilty when they are caregiving because they cannot attend to their work tasks.
Despite this dynamic, most parents plan to keep their children in virtual learning, even as two-thirds of parents report that their children’s school is currently open or planning to reopen for in-person learning. The same number of parents, 66%, also report that they are keeping their children in 100% remote or virtual learning. Only 20% plan to have their children participate in 100% in-person, classroom learning, and 57% of parents are either against the idea of sending their children back to in-person school or are unsure.
Working parents have a lot on their shoulders right now. As organizations implement ways to help them, managers should be educated on the value of these programs and how to encourage their employees to utilize them without fearing for their jobs for feeling guilty.